~25 music-video files are on disk but never ingested by Jellyfin — 4 folders short of their file count (not multi-version merging) #640

Open
opened 2026-07-26 00:45:20 +02:00 by timothy · 0 comments
Owner

Found while verifying the #615 fix. Not caused by that change — pre-existing, and distinct from the multi-version merging #615 fixed.

Method

After the #615 rename, I swept all 30 music-video folders comparing on-disk video files (recursive) against Jellyfin items and their MediaSources count. The merging check is MediaSources > Items.

Merging result: 0 of 30 folders — #615's class of bug is fully eliminated, including the two it reported.

But four folders have fewer Jellyfin items than files, with MediaSources == Items (so this is not merging — the files simply never got ingested):

folder files on disk (recursive) Jellyfin items missing
HipHopHistoryGuy 255 236 19
Cookin Soul 81 77 4
Glastonbury Concerts 188 187 1
Vaporwave 205 204 1

Total ~25 files. Cookin Soul's gap is the same one already visible in #615's table (81 files / 79 NFOs / 77 items) — that issue noted it in passing but scoped it out.

None of these folders have subdirectories except Glastonbury Concerts (3), so the counts are directly comparable.

Not a regression, and one measurement caveat

An earlier pass also flagged Concert Films (1 file / 37 items) — that was a measurement artifact: my first count was non-recursive and the folder has 36 subdirectories. Recursively it is 37/37, exactly reconciled. Recording this because a non-recursive file count silently produces false gaps for nested folders, which is easy to mistake for real breakage.

Likely causes to check (none confirmed)

  • unsupported/odd container or codec Jellyfin skips
  • filename characters the resolver rejects
  • missing/malformed NFO for those specific files (Cookin Soul is known to be 81 files / 79 NFOs — 2 of its 4 missing items may simply be the untagged pair)
  • files added after the last full scan that a subsequent incremental scan didn't pick up

Impact

Lower than #615 — these folders still yield many items, so no channel loops a single title. It's a silent completeness gap: a collection built from one of these folders is quietly missing content, with no error anywhere.

Done-when

  • The ~25 missing files are identified by name (disk set minus Jellyfin Path set, per folder)
  • Root cause determined for at least the 19 in HipHopHistoryGuy (the bulk of it)
  • Either ingested, or consciously excluded with the reason recorded here
  • Adversarial review passed
Found while verifying the #615 fix. **Not caused by that change** — pre-existing, and distinct from the multi-version merging #615 fixed. ## Method After the #615 rename, I swept **all 30** music-video folders comparing on-disk video files (recursive) against Jellyfin items and their `MediaSources` count. The merging check is `MediaSources > Items`. **Merging result: 0 of 30 folders** — #615's class of bug is fully eliminated, including the two it reported. But four folders have fewer Jellyfin items than files, with `MediaSources == Items` (so this is *not* merging — the files simply never got ingested): | folder | files on disk (recursive) | Jellyfin items | missing | |---|---|---|---| | `HipHopHistoryGuy` | 255 | 236 | **19** | | `Cookin Soul` | 81 | 77 | **4** | | `Glastonbury Concerts` | 188 | 187 | 1 | | `Vaporwave` | 205 | 204 | 1 | Total ~25 files. `Cookin Soul`'s gap is the same one already visible in #615's table (81 files / 79 NFOs / 77 items) — that issue noted it in passing but scoped it out. None of these folders have subdirectories except `Glastonbury Concerts` (3), so the counts are directly comparable. ## Not a regression, and one measurement caveat An earlier pass also flagged `Concert Films` (1 file / 37 items) — that was a **measurement artifact**: my first count was non-recursive and the folder has 36 subdirectories. Recursively it is 37/37, exactly reconciled. Recording this because a non-recursive file count silently produces false gaps for nested folders, which is easy to mistake for real breakage. ## Likely causes to check (none confirmed) - unsupported/odd container or codec Jellyfin skips - filename characters the resolver rejects - missing/malformed NFO for those specific files (`Cookin Soul` is known to be 81 files / 79 NFOs — 2 of its 4 missing items may simply be the untagged pair) - files added after the last full scan that a subsequent incremental scan didn't pick up ## Impact Lower than #615 — these folders still yield many items, so no channel loops a single title. It's a silent completeness gap: a collection built from one of these folders is quietly missing content, with no error anywhere. ## Done-when - [ ] The ~25 missing files are identified by name (disk set minus Jellyfin `Path` set, per folder) - [ ] Root cause determined for at least the 19 in `HipHopHistoryGuy` (the bulk of it) - [ ] Either ingested, or consciously excluded with the reason recorded here - [ ] Adversarial review passed
timothy added the bugjellyfinpriority: low labels 2026-07-26 00:45:36 +02:00
Sign in to join this conversation.
1 Participants
Notifications
Due Date
No due date set.
Dependencies

No dependencies set.

Reference: timothy/ersatztv#640